If you asked me what my favorite restaurant is, I’d tell you Olive Garden and that I absolutely adore a plate of Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo served up. What I don’t love is the cost that eating out, especially at Olive Garden costs. So what is a frugal person to do? I could spend time earning free Olive Garden gift Cards or I could make one of my favorite copycat recipes instead! This copycat Olive Garden Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo recipe is perfect for those of us who love the taste, but hate the cost! This copycat Olive Garden recipe is one of my favorite recipes that uses heavy cream. If you don’t have heavy cream on hand though, no worries. My heavy cream substitute should work just as well.
There is something comforting about a plate of pasta with moist chicken chunks and a creamy, decadent Alfredo sauce. Seriously comforting and oh my…so very, very good! This is one of my favorite dishes to make (okay besides my banana nut muffins recipe because that’s my absolute favorite…today) and you would be surprised at how easy it actually is to do! The secret is really in the sauce. It is so close to the original recipe that you truly won’t believe that it is copycat Olive Garden recipe and not the real thing! My family actually thinks it tastes better than Olive Garden! I know…blasphemy, right? It’ll be okay. Try my sauce and it’ll all be okay.
Copycat Olive Garden Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo
This recipe depends on the sauce but fortunately for all of us, this copycat Olive Garden sauce is actually really easy to make, even if it can seem like it’s very hard. The reason it seems hard to make is that the cream will scorch very easily if you’re not careful. Don’t let that fool you into thinking that you can’t make it though. You absolutely, 100% can make it and it will taste awesome when you do! Also a word on the Parmesan cheese. Use fresh. Don’t use the stuff in the shaker can. Yes, the Kraft Parmesan shaker can is easier but the taste won’t be any easier on your taste buds. Finally, before you head off to the kitchen, keep in mind that I’m not kidding when I say that this sauce can scorch very easily. To keep that from happening, you’ll want to be working on the next step as one is being finished. You’ll understand exactly what I mean when you take a look at the directions below!
If you’re looking for an easier restaurant copycat recipe, I highly suggest you try my copycat Red Lobster Shrimp Scampi recipe or my Copycat Olive Garden Chicken Gnocchi Soup recipe. Both are amazing along side of my copycat Red Lobster Stuffed Mushrooms recipe, tend to be cheaper and are much easier to make.
This recipe can be expensive to make because of the cream. It won’t be as expensive as actually eating at Olive Garden would be, but it’s more expensive than the average meal I post here on the blog. One of the ways that I like to save money when I’m making it is by using chicken that I have bought from Zaycon Foods. Zaycon Foods offers farm fresh boneless, skinless chicken breast and with the prices I get, it makes this recipe considerably cheaper.
You Will Need:
- 2-3 boneless skinless chicken breast
- 1/2 to 1 lb cooked fettuccine noodles
- 1/2 cup butter
- 2 tablespoons cream cheese
- 1 pint heavy cream (or make a homemade heavy cream substitute like THIS one)
- 1-2 teaspoons garlic powder + more to taste if you want
- chopped parsley
- salt and pepper, to taste
- 2/3 – 3/4 cup fresh grated Parmesan cheese
To start, cook the chicken breasts by wrapping each one in a piece of aluminum foil and sealing the edges tight to form an envelope. Bake on an un-greased cookie sheet at 25 minutes or so or until they’re done. Cooking your chicken this way keeps the chicken’s natural juices in so that you end up with a piece of chicken that is moist and flavorful with very little effort. I cook mine this way anytime that I need shredded or chunked chicken. You don’t need any seasonings when you cook it this way, but it isn’t going to hurt if you do season it with a bit of garlic powder and onion powder to your preference. Once your chicken is fully cooked, cut into chunks of whatever size your family prefers.
While the chicken is cooking, start your pasta water boiling in a heavy bottomed pot and cook according to the directions on the package. I always add a drop or two of olive oil to the water while it’s boiling. Not sure if it actually does help keep it from sticking, but I do it anyway.
Copycat Olive Garden Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo Recipe
As you boil the pasta, melt the butter for the sauce in a medium saucepan over medium heat. Nothing higher and nothing lower. If your stove only has numbers, 4-5 should be okay. Don’t use margarine in this. Margarine is the devil and well; almost quite literally plastic. Your taste buds and your health will thank you for using the real stuff. Salted or unsalted is your preference, but if I use salted, then I tend to not use any other salt in the recipe so it doesn’t overwhelm.
When your butter is melted, add the 2 tablespoons of cream cheese and whisk it around the pan until it’s all creamy and melts too. You’ll want to pretty much whisk constantly so that it doesn’t burn. Once it’s fully melted, slowly whisk in the heavy cream. Don’t substitute milk. Don’t substitute half and half. You must use real heavy cream. I do make a good quality heavy cream substitute sometimes, but I’ve never used it in this recipe. If you try to, do so at your own risk and don’t yell at me if it doesn’t turn out. If you need a good, quality whisk, I can’t recommend THIS one high enough. It’s the one I use and fantastic!
Add in the garlic powder, parsley and a pinch or three of salt & pepper if you’re using it and keep whisking. Whisk gently here folks. We’re not stirring per se’…we’re whisking and there is a difference.
Bring to a simmer and let simmer for 25 minutes. If you need to reduce your heat, do so. You don’t want it getting to a full rolling boil. This will burn VERY quickly if you let it. Take it from experience – it smells REALLY badly when it does. Whisk often. I’ll tell you the truth. I whisk it almost constantly. I don’t walk away, I stand there and watch my sauce take shape…it’s the smell that draws me in. In any case, you want a low simmer on it constantly.
Remove from heat and quickly stir in the grated cheese. You can stir here. Stirring is okay and widely accepted at this stage.
TASTE before serving. Taste a small bite to see if your seasonings are okay. If not, adjust as needed. Put the spoon down! I said taste, not eat the whole pan. (You probably could with this stuff). Once you’ve adjusted your seasonings, you’re ready to eat!
Plate the fettuccine noodles first then top the noodles with a generous serving of chicken breast. Then, ladle your copycat Olive Garden Alfredo sauce over the top. Garnish with a bit of Parmesan cheese and serve hot!
Okay, just a couple of other things:
Your sauce may be thin when you get done. That is okay. It WILL thicken up a bit as it cools. As I said earlier, the sauce in this can burn very quickly. That is the main reason that I do not walk away when it is on the stove. Pay attention or your whole house will smell like scorched milk. Romano cheese can be substituted for Parmesan cheese with no issues and you can garnish with a tiny bit of homemade mozzarella cheese as well if you prefer. If you want to add something else to it, try adding mushrooms, substituting the chicken for shrimp or using a vegetable based pasta.
Finally, this recipe does not freeze well. Your sauce will separate into some gloppy concoction that just isn’t edible. I wish it did, but that isn’t the case.
Copycat Olive Garden Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo
Ingredients
- 2-3 chicken breast bone and skin removed
- 1/2 to 1 lb fettuccine noodles cooked
- 1/2 cup butter
- 2 tablespoons cream cheese
- 1 pint heavy cream
- 1-2 teaspoons garlic powder + more to taste if you want
- a few springs of fresh parsley chopped
- salt and pepper enough to taste
- 2/3 - 3/4 cup fresh Parmesan cheese grated
Instructions
- To start, cook the chicken breasts by wrapping each one in foil and sealing the edges tight (to form an envelope) and baking on a cookie sheet at 25 minutes or so or until they're done. Cooking your chicken this way keeps the chickens natural juices in so that you end up with a piece of chicken that is moist and flavorful with very little effort. I cook mine this way anytime that I need shredded or chunked chicken. You don't need any seasonings when you cook it this way, but it isn't going to hurt if you do season it a bit to your preference. Once your chicken is fully cooked, cut into chunks of whatever size your family prefers.
- While the chicken is cooking, start your pasta and cook according to the directions on the package.
- As you boil the pasta, melt the butter for the sauce in a medium saucepan over medium heat. Nothing higher and nothing lower.
- When your butter is melted, add the 2 tablespoons of cream cheese and whisk it around the pan until it's all creamy and melts too. You'll want to pretty much whisk constantly so that it doesn't burn. Once it's fully melted, slowly whisk in the heavy cream. Don't substitute milk. Don't substitute half and half. You must use real heavy cream.
- Add in the garlic powder, parsley and a pinch or three of salt & pepper if you're using it and keep whisking. Whisk gently.
- Bring to a simmer and let simmer for 25 minutes. If you need to reduce your heat, do so. You don't want it getting to a full rolling boil. This will burn VERY quickly if you let it Whisk often.
- Remove from heat and quickly stir in the grated cheese.
- TASTE before serving. Taste a small bite to see if your seasonings are okay. If not, adjust as needed. Once you've adjusted your seasonings, you're ready to eat! Serve the fettuccine noodles
- Plate the fettuccine noodles first then top the noodles with a generous serving of chicken breast. Ladle the copycat Olive Garden Alfredo sauce over the top. Garnish with a bit of Parmesan cheese and serve hot!
*Originally Posted in May 2014/ Updated June 2018
Join over 2500 other people in our exclusive Facebook community! Ask questions, get answers and more!
Stacy Ott
I earned over $100,000 blogging last year! Click here to learn how to start a blog and make money blogging!
Latest posts by Stacy Ott (see all)
- How We Are Living Frugally in 2019 – Week 2– What We Ate and How We Saved - January 15, 2019
- Budgeting House Expenses with Home Warranties in 2019 - January 15, 2019
- 35+ Must-Have Organizing Supplies for Any Budget - January 15, 2019
I’m Stacy, CEO extraordinaire and 1/4 of the Six Dollar Family. I'm on a journey to become a six figure family and I would love if you came along with me! We'll kick off our shoes, sip sweet tea, eat loads of goodies, save some money and maybe even learn a thing or two along the way!
What’s the best way you’ve found to reheat this dish?
In the microwave covered with a damp paper towel to keep it from drying out. Otherwise, add a tiny bit of water to it and warm on low. The water you add will help the sauce come back to its originally consistency, just be careful not to add too much. 🙂
I’ll try it! My problem is that when i microwave it normally it becomes really oily..
Hmmm…I’ve never had that issue. Try the warming it on the stove and see if that keeps it from doing that.
Omg!!!!! Thank you for this recipe! This is my first time making it & it is delicious! For sure I making this again. Olive Garden who?! LOL!
How many people does this recipe sever? I have a family of 4, in which all eats adult size servings. Should I double the recipe to be safe?
Amy, we are a family of 3 and usually only get 1 adult sized serving each so I would suggest doubling just to be safe. At least for the first time you make it anyhow.
your directions are very thorough. thank you very much
This was phenomenal. my picky daughter asked me to make it everyday??. Took a little elbow power with a watchful eye as I took you heed to warning in regards to it scortching but it was all worth. Saved in my “Successful Recipes” book.
I’m thrilled you liked it Latoya. It’s one of our favorites too. 🙂
Question, can this sauce be prepared the night before and stored in the fridge overnight.. Have you ever tried that?
Hi Tamara, I wouldn’t unless you’re going to have time to stand over it and warm it slowly on the stove. It tends to separate when cooled then re-heated unless it’s done very slowly.
We have tried many different alfredo recipes. We really liked this one, and oddly enough, it seemed “lighter” than most, despite the cream. 🙂 We like to bake our leftovers. We simply mix the leftover pasta and sauce, and add extras, if desired — like cooked broccoli or mushrooms. Place in individual au gratin dishes, cover, and refrigerate. When you are ready to eat them, just uncover and bake at 350 degrees for 20 minutes or so….until hot and bubbly around the edges. For another option, you can top with grated cheese and/or panko crumbs. Good to have on hand for quick lunches or suppers, especially for just one or two people.
I just finished cleaning the kitchen after this amazing meal. The sauce was delicious and perfect. My sauce did get a little too thick at the end, but I added a little half and half to get it to a better consistency. Really amazing recipe, though!
My Girl Scouts are going to try this at camp this weekend!
I made your recipe for chicken fettuccine last night. I trippled the recipe to feed about 16 teen aged girls. They absolutely loved it. I made it exactly like you wrote the recipe, I had no problems and it turned out fantastic. Thanks for the great recipe.
Aw, I’m glad! Thanks for letting me know!
I followed your recipe and instructions and let tell you, Olive Garden should hire me! It came out perfect! Thank you!
What temperature do I cook the chicken?
If you are baking it, I would wrap each piece in foil tightly (no seasoning) then bake at 350 until done. It won’t need water or anything to keep it moist. It will make its own broth and come out flavorful.
I made this the other night & it was SO delicious! Everyone was raving it was the best Alfredo they’ve ever had, even better than Olive Garden 🙂 I used a tablespoon of minced garlic since that’s what I had on hand (sautéed in the butter a few minutes before adding the cream cheese), & the flavor was perfect. Thanks so much for sharing your recipe!
I made this for dinner tonight…. It was GREAT!! My husband loved it. Thank you for sharing the reciepe!
I’m planning on making this for my husbands birthday dinner. What do you think of keeping it warm in the crock pot for a bit?
Kristen, I would think it would be okay but I would be concerned about it becoming too dry.
I made this for my family tonight. It was a big hit. Our new fave.
4 years ago I made chicken alfrado for my now fiance. I used a friend’s recipe and needless to say it was a complete disaster milky flavorless mess….. I have not cooked it since. Long story short tonight I was brave enough to cook this recipe of yours and completely redeemed myself thank you for the recipe my fiance loveeeeeddd it smiles all around 🙂
I’m glad I could help 🙂
Am I allowed to use heavy whipping cream? I can’t seem to find and heavy cream at the store and they seem very similar (at least what I searched up said)
It’s the same thing Karla. Just worded differently.
Can I put chicken, sauce, and pasta together and serve it that way? Or will the sauce thicken too fast. Thinking to make this to feed the guys working at our church. So I’d have to travel with it? Will this work? Thanks
You could put it all together without too much issue.
Wondering about other cheese substitutes. I cannot have aged cheeses (migraine thing) and really miss alfredo sauce. Wondering about monterey jack….you think it would work?
Monterey Jack should be just fine, but keep in mind that it may change the taste a bit.
I tried twice tonight to make this and when I put the cream cheese in, it broke down into tiny balls, separated or whatever it is called. Never became creamy. Can anyone tell me what I did wrong?
Jeanette, were you using cream cheese that had been frozen and thawed? I’ve never had that happen when I have made it, but if your cream cheese had been previously frozen, it would have changed the consistency of it and possibly caused the change.
I tried this recipe today. Best I’ve ever made! On the first try it came out perfect! Followed your direction to the T and yessss! Lol..my new forever go to recipe for Chicken Alfredo. Thanks for sharing this recipe! God bless!
What temp do we cook the chicken at?
Melissa, if you’re baking it in foil, I would do 375° or so.
I wonder if you could make the sauce in a double boiler, eliminating the chance of it burning? What are your thoughts?
I’ve never tried that Colleen, but it might work. The sauce really isn’t hard to make, but it is cream based. All you really need to do is keep the cream from scorching.
I am feeding 8 adults and 2 children. Should I double or triple this recipe.
I would double it at least, but be careful. I’m not certain how well it will double.