Spooky Oreo Eyeball Cookies

Think of any Halloween movie and there is almost always one scene they all have in common; creepy eyeballs watching the main character! These spooky Oreo eyeball cookies are just like those eyes! Made with sweet candy, Oreo cookies and creepy bloodshot eyes, these are one Halloween cookie everyone will love!

---

---

For some, Halloween is a time of scaring others, being scared themselves and gore, but for me, it’s a time of fun recipes and Halloween crafts; especially Halloween cookies and candy. These “creepy” candy Oreo eyeball cookies are just the start! They are creative, fun and kid-friendly too! No tricks here! Just treats!

I have made these Oreo eyeball cookies for years, and I am never disappointed They’re perfect for Halloween parties, class treats, or just a fun afternoon in the kitchen. Cookie Monsters of all ages are sure to love them! I always seem to have the ingredients on hand too. They come together using items, and there’s no baking required, so less mess and no fuss.

They’re also super easy to customize so if you’re working with food allergies or preferences, there are plenty of alternatives out there. Gluten-free sandwich cookies work just as well, and there are dye-free candies and food coloring gel you can swap in too. I’ve even used chocolate chips in place of the center “pupil” when I was out of M&M’s, and they still turned out great. This recipe isn’t picky, and that makes it one of my go to Halloween cookie recipes.

Just a note; you can use brown or black M&M candies depending on what is available when you go to make your candy eyes.

These candy eyeballs hit just the right note with both kids and adults alike. They’re creepy enough to get a laugh or gasp from kids, but they’re not so over-the-top that someone will be afraid to eat them. And believe me, they will get eaten. I’ve never had a batch make it past the first day.

The best part, though, is how fun they are to make. It’s one of those recipes that turns into a craft project, especially if you’ve got kids helping out. My daughter used to love decorating each “eyeball” with her own twist; adding little veins or playing with different color combinations. You can use different color Lifesavers or use all red Lifesavers. After all, all they really are is a cookie with cream for the irises, a dot of frosting, a small amount of red gel and a candy piece for the pupil. It’s a simple way to get everyone in the Halloween spirit without turning your kitchen into a disaster zone.

These Oreo eyeball cookies also travel well. Just pack them between layers of parchment paper in an airtight container and be sure they don’t get squished. Or, if you’re like me, you’ll worry too much about that and will pack them into a single layer on a covered baking sheet instead. They are stored at room temperature too so refrigeration is not needed.

Whether you’re planning a full-blown Halloween bash or just want to make something festive for movie night, these little eyeball cookies are a solid choice. These monster eyeball cookies affordable, fun to make, and easy enough that you can pull them together even at the last minute. And really, that’s what makes them one of my favorite Halloween cookie traditions. No stress and no mess; just a great Halloween recipe that the whole family can get involved with.