Creepy Candy Eyeballs

This post may contain affiliate or referral links that help keep this site running. For more information about this, please see our disclosure policy.

Halloween is great and while it’s one of my favorite holidays, I honestly don’t see a need for a whole ton of gore. A little bit of creepy gore though is perfectly fine with me. Take these creepy eyeball cookies for example. They’re creepy without being too creepy for little ones and well? Look at them! They’re super fun!

Aside from being really fun though, they’re also crazy easy to put together! You only need a few items and yes, the kids can help! These would be the perfect Halloween slumber party activity too. I can very easily see my Emma and her bestie making these one weekend while watching creepy movies in between giggles and screams.

You will need:

Oreos
Lifesavers (Your choice of regular or gummy)
M&M’s
Wilton Blood Red Sparkle Gel Frosting

Grab your Oreo’s and split them in half. You only need the side with cream so feel free to eat the other half of the cookie. Place a dab of frosting in the middle of each cookie then place 1 Lifesaver on top. The dab of frosting will act as glue to help keep the candy on the cookie.

Next, add another dab of frosting in the middle of the lifesaver and attach an M&M for the pupil of each eye.

Next, take the frosting and create blood vessels on the outside of each eye to create the bloodshot look.

Enjoy!

Creepy Candy Eyeballs

Save Print

Creepy gore without going overboard, these creepy candy eyeballs are perfect for your next Halloween party!

Author: Stacy Barr

Ingredients

Oreos
Lifesavers (Your choice of regular or gummy)
M&M’s
Red Wilton Sparkle Gel Frosting

Instructions

Split each Oreo in half saving the side with the cream.
Place a dab of frosting in the middle of each cookie then place 1 Lifesaver on top.
Next, add another dab of frosting in the middle of the lifesaver and attach an M&M for the pupil of each eye.
Use the red frosting to create blood vessels around each eye.

Join over 2500 other people in our exclusive Facebook community! Ask questions, get answers and more!

Six Dollar Family - Frugal Living, Budget Recipes, DIY, Homesteading

Facebook Group · 2,503 members

Join Group

Are you working toward being a Six Dollar Family? If so, these personal finance tips, frugal living tips, awesome recipes, and more will help you get ...

About
Latest Posts

Follow Me

Stacy Ott

Stacy Ott is the face and brain behind the frugal living and lifestyle blog Six Dollar Family as well as The Genealogy Queen and a few others.By the age of 30, Stacy had overcome an alcohol addiction, a drug addiction, divorce, survived domestic violence, and had built a life for herself and her daughter after spending 10 months in a homeless shelter. Stacy is passionate about homeless advocacy and addiction education. Her first book, also called Six Dollar Family is available on Amazon.

I earned over $100,000 blogging last year! Click here to learn how to start a blog and make money blogging!