Creepy Candy Eyeballs

Creepy gore without going overboard, these creepy candy eyeballs are perfect for your next Halloween party!
Author Stacy Barr


  • Oreos
  • Lifesavers Your choice of regular or gummy
  • M&M’s
  • Red Wilton Sparkle Gel Frosting


  • Split each Oreo in half saving the side with the cream.
  • Place a dab of frosting in the middle of each cookie then place 1 Lifesaver on top.
  • Next, add another dab of frosting in the middle of the lifesaver and attach an M&M for the pupil of each eye.
  • Use the red frosting to create blood vessels around each eye.